Google Is Feeding Rank Trackers the Wrong Results

Human Verified

Share to: , and

A magnifying glass over jumbled, out-of-order search result cards, one card highlighted in amber with a warning symbol

Google has been serving rank tracking tools results pages that look normal but list the wrong sites since mid-September. The industry calls them poisoned SERPs, and every major tracker appears affected. The bad data overlaps two Google updates, so some SEOs may have acted on false drops.

What a poisoned SERP looks like

A poisoned page replaces most of the sites that rank for a query with other sites, and nothing on the page reveals the problem. A tracked site is about twenty times more likely to vanish from the top ten when a SERP is poisoned. Social and forum results take over.

Foreign domains appear more often for United States keywords, AI Overviews show up less, and image packs appear nearly twice as often. Results can also drift off topic. The wrong rankings usually correct themselves after several days, but the tracker has already stored them as real.

How widespread is it

Estimates vary widely because each vendor measures the problem differently. Nozzle puts the average at 27.6 percent since mid-September, with a peak of 68.6 percent. DataForSEO reports about twenty to thirty percent, while AccuRanker reports only one to two percent for October.

A long squeeze on scrapers

Poisoning is the latest step in a series of changes that made Google results harder to collect. Google began requiring JavaScript in January 2025, dropped the num equals 100 parameter in September, and sued SerpApi in December. A federal judge dismissed its DMCA claims in July 2026.

Google confirmed goto URL redirects on result links in August 2026, describing them as technical measures against abuse. The first poisoned pages appeared in Nozzle’s data on 20 September, four days before the September spam update began. The November core update added more real movement.

Why is Google doing it

Google has not commented on poisoned SERPs at all. Its only on-record comment from this period concerns the goto redirects, which it describes as part of a long history of technical measures against evolving abuse. Whether poisoning is intentional remains unconfirmed.

The leading industry theory is that rank trackers are collateral damage. The real target, under that theory, is bulk scraping of Google results to feed AI answer engines, a process known as grounding. Search Engine Journal also suggests the measures may target spammers trying to reverse-engineer how pages rank.

Vendors are adapting

Nearly every major rank tracker has acknowledged the problem and changed how it handles the data. Semrush now filters out results that are obviously incorrect, and DataForSEO takes a similar approach. SISTRIX has narrowed its focus to the top ten and disabled on-demand updates since September.

Our Read

The overlap is what makes this dangerous. Real movement from the September spam update and the November core update arrived in the same window as poisoned data, so a genuine drop and a fake one looked identical in a tracker.

Search Console is the only source of truth here, because it uses real user impressions rather than scraped pages. If a tracker shows a drop while Search Console shows steady impressions, the discrepancy itself is the signal. Trust the first-party data, and treat the tracker as a hint.

Why It Matters

Why it matters: rank trackers underpin how the whole SEO industry judges success, and AI visibility tools are built on the same scraped pages. When a quarter of the data can be wrong, every report, client meeting and budget decision built on it carries the same doubt.

Background

Nozzle coined the term poisoned SERP in a study published on 10 October, after first spotting the pattern in mid-September. Other vendors confirmed the findings publicly in the following weeks, and the problem hit a new high on 2 November. Google has said nothing about it since.

Source: Search Engine Land explainer

Share to: , and

Faheem R. Khattak

Senior automation engineer and AI marketing journo covering LLMs, algorithms, analytics, core updates, Bing search, and technical SEO.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Optional Take Tag:

🛡️ Spam protection: Honeypot + Time-Trap Active

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.