A Muslim author has sued xAI, the company behind Grok, after users of the chatbot stripped the hijab from her selfie and rendered her in lingerie and a bikini. Amani Al-Khatahtbeh filed the federal complaint on Wednesday, seeking damages for each alleged violation.
The Lawsuit
The complaint, filed in a federal court in Northern California, accuses xAI of intentional distribution of nonconsensual sexual images, design and marketing defect, negligence and emotional distress. It seeks up to $250,000 per violation of California civil law. xAI did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Al-Khatahtbeh, the founder of the media company Muslim Girl, announced the case on Capitol Hill. Her lawyer, Hillary Nappi, argues that Grok was designed in a way that allows the sexual exploitation of women and children, and that xAI should have built in safeguards.
The January Incident
The case traces back to January 1, when Al-Khatahtbeh posted a selfie from the inauguration of Zohran Mamdani, New York City’s first Muslim mayor. She wore a black hijab and a purple fur coat. Within hours, replies began asking Grok to undress her.
The requests were explicit: remove the hijab, swap the coat for a bikini, change the outfit to lingerie. Grok carried them out, producing images of her in various states of undress that circulated to tens of thousands of people. She described the experience as a violation.
She reported the images to X, but says they were not taken down immediately. When the abuse began she called 911, showed officers the pictures, and was told there was nothing they could do. The police took a report and left.
The Defective-Product Argument
The complaint’s central claim is that Grok is a defective product. It argues that xAI could and should have designed the system to refuse prompts that remove religious garments from images of real people, or that create sexualised depictions of identifiable, non-consenting people.
The filing says the flaw is structural, not accidental. Models trained on large, uncurated image datasets readily recognise garments such as hijabs, abayas and sarees, so a prompt directing their removal is trivially easy to execute unless the system is designed to refuse it.
Why It Matters
This is the first lawsuit to focus specifically on Grok removing women’s hijabs. It lands as regulators and courts worldwide are already circling the chatbot, and as xAI fights earlier suits over its data centre. The case could set the first binding precedent on AI liability for user-prompted images.
A January report from the Center for Countering Digital Harm estimated Grok generated around three million photorealistic sexualised images on X in eleven days, including about 23,000 of children. A review of 500 images found five percent targeted modest religious attire.
Our Read
The defective-product framing is the story here, not the damages figure. If a court accepts that Grok’s design — not just its users — caused the harm, every image model that edits photos of real people faces the same question, and ‘the user asked for it’ stops being a defence.
xAI’s own response in January weakens its position. Limiting the image tools to paying subscribers did not stop the pictures being made; it meant users had to pay xAI to make them. That choice will be Exhibit A for the argument that the company knew and profited anyway.
Background
xAI has also faced a NAACP case over its turbines, but this is the first suit to put Grok’s image tools themselves on trial. Canada found xAI violated its federal privacy laws, France opened a criminal probe, and many inquiries are still open.
Source: WIRED report, The Print report


0 Comments