Italy’s data protection authority has fined Meta €805 million — about $887 million — after finding that Facebook accessed Android users’ photographs and videos without their consent. The penalty, announced on Saturday, targets a Facebook feature that scans photo galleries to suggest images for posts, and it affects roughly 20 million smartphone users in Italy. Meta has 60 days to switch the feature off by default and ask users for separate, explicit consent. The fine is among the largest an Italian authority has ever imposed on a technology company.
What Facebook did
The feature at the centre of the case is called “Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook”. Introduced in 2023, it was switched on by default and drew on the photos and videos stored on a user’s phone — along with their metadata — to propose images and clips the person might want to post.
The problem, in the regulator’s view, was consent. Facebook asked users for a single, app-wide permission to reach their photo galleries, but the notice given beforehand did not make clear that the same permission would also let Facebook generate suggestions from the images stored there. Users were never told, and never separately asked, about that second use.
Why the fine is so large
The authority weighed two aggravating factors when setting the amount: the sheer number of people affected, and the fact that the practice is still going on — for users who have not updated the app, and for those who already gave consent under the old wording. It also cited what it called Meta’s lack of cooperation during the investigation.
The €805 million figure is equivalent to about 0.47 percent of Meta’s worldwide revenue, the authority said. The investigation began in July 2025, after a complaint from a consumer protection organisation in Bolzano, in northern Italy. Meta was not immediately available for comment when the decision was announced.

What Meta must do now
Meta has 60 days to disable the gallery-suggestion feature by default and to introduce a separate consent request that clearly explains why Facebook needs access to a phone’s photos and videos, and how the feature can be switched off. Until users give that explicit consent, the feature must stay off.
The decision deliberately leaves one question open. The investigation did not examine whether the photos and videos were used to train Meta’s artificial intelligence models — a practice the company denies. The authority said it reserved the right to assess separately a newer feature, launched in 2026, that lets gallery content be processed in the cloud.
Our Read
The size of the fine is the story, but the reasoning is the warning. Regulators are no longer treating consent as a box to tick at install time; they are asking whether each use of personal data was explained and agreed to. A single permission that quietly covers a second purpose is now, in Italy’s reading, a violation in itself.
For Meta, the timing is awkward. The company is pushing its AI assistant into its apps, and every new feature touching photos will now face the same question: was the user told, and did the user agree? A fine worth half a percent of global revenue is a rounding error. The 60-day fix, and the precedent it sets, is not.
Why It Matters
Twenty million people is a large number, but the principle reaches further than Italy. The same consent logic applies to every app that reads a phone’s photo library — and to the AI tools built on top of those libraries. If a gallery suggestion needs its own consent, an AI feature fed on gallery images will need one too.
The ruling lands amid hard regulatory scrutiny for Meta. Nonprofits have sued to halt frontier AI development in California, US senators have pressed Meta over bystander privacy, and Meta’s AI push — including Muse, its superintelligence effort — is drawing attention on both sides of the Atlantic. Privacy enforcement is now part of the AI story, not a separate one.
Background
Italy has been among Europe’s most assertive regulators on digital privacy. Its data protection authority temporarily restricted ChatGPT in 2023 over data concerns and has repeatedly sanctioned Meta. Weeks before this fine, a judge in New Mexico ordered Meta to pay $25 billion after finding the company had misled the public about how it handled Facebook user data.
Source: Reuters report and BBC report.


0 Comments