UK Court Forces Government to Admit Secret Apple Encryption Order

Human Verified

Share to: , and

A judge's gavel beside a smartphone showing a padlock in a courtroom

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal confirmed on Thursday that the British government served Apple with a secret order demanding access to its customers’ encrypted data, rejecting the Home Office’s claim that admitting the order existed would damage national security, in a ruling that opens the long-running dispute to public scrutiny.

What the tribunal decided

The tribunal found the government had not shown that confirming the order, known as a technical capability notice, would harm national security. It noted the amount of information already public meant confirmation would do little, if any, damage to the country’s interests.

Three judges — Lady Carmichael, Mr Justice Chamberlain and Mr Justice Johnson — heard the case after a September hearing. They also handed down private judgments that cannot be disclosed without damaging the public interest, according to the tribunal’s ruling.

How the secrecy unravelled

The Home Office had refused to confirm or deny the order under its longstanding policy on security matters. But the tribunal found officials had already confirmed it to newspaper journalists and to United States officials, undermining the argument that secrecy could still be maintained.

A leak to the Washington Post first revealed in January 2025 that the Home Office had issued the notice, seeking access to end-to-end encrypted messages and data stored by Apple’s customers around the world in iCloud. Tulsi Gabbard, the former US intelligence chief, confirmed it publicly in August.

The demand Apple refused

The original notice sought a back door into encrypted cloud backups belonging to American and British citizens. After months of negotiation with President Donald Trump’s administration, that demand was dropped — but in July Britain issued a second notice applying only to Apple’s British customers.

Rather than comply, Apple withdrew its Advanced Data Protection service from new users in Britain. The optional setting gives iCloud backups, photos and notes end-to-end protection, and Apple has said it never built a backdoor into its products and never will.

What happens next

Thursday’s ruling settles only whether the order can be acknowledged, not whether it is lawful. The tribunal will decide at later hearings how much of the notice itself can be disclosed, and a trial on the substance of the case is not expected until next year.

Apple is challenging the lawfulness of the home secretary’s powers to issue such notices on five grounds, alongside separate challenges from Privacy International and Liberty. The tribunal found most of Apple’s arguments can be heard in open court without harming national security.

Our Read

The ruling matters less for what it reveals than for what it stops. For nearly two years the government used ‘neither confirm nor deny’ as a wall around a policy with global consequences, while its briefings told the press the opposite. The tribunal called that bluff with the government’s words.

That precedent travels. Every government that wants a back door into encrypted services will face the same question in public, and every company asked to build one can point to a court that refused to let the demand hide. Encryption, the tribunal ruled, is too important to debate in secret.

Why It Matters

The case sets the terms for the encryption fight everywhere. If Britain can compel Apple to retain access to encrypted data, other governments will ask for the same — and the ruling means the public will know the demand exists, and can argue about it openly.

Background

Apple launched its first challenge in early 2025, and the tribunal ruled in April that year that the company could be named and the subject of its claim made public. The first claim was later dismissed after a change of circumstances, and the precise terms of the notice remain secret.

Source: Reuters’ tribunal ruling report and Computer Weekly’s court coverage.

Share to: , and

Faheem R. Khattak

Senior automation engineer and AI marketing journo covering LLMs, algorithms, analytics, core updates, Bing search, and technical SEO.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Optional Take Tag:

🛡️ Spam protection: Honeypot + Time-Trap Active

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.