Longtime Google advertisers are cutting their search budgets as artificial intelligence reshapes the results page. Ads that once sat at the top now appear below AI-written answers, or not at all, and the money is moving elsewhere after years of steady spending.
Marshall Evans, a North Carolina marketer who has bought Google search ads for small businesses for more than a decade, has moved money away over the past six months. For one trophy seller, monthly search spending fell 75%, from $2,000 to $500, in about a year.
Costs Climb as Ads Sink
Evans is putting the freed budget toward streaming services such as Tubi, rival search engines such as Bing, and social sites such as Reddit and Nextdoor. The shift is a practical response to a simple problem: the ads cost more and are seen less.
Max Anderson, chief executive of OnlyFinder, tells a similar story. His Google search ads sometimes do not appear at all, or show below an AI Overview, and he says his costs have probably tripled or quadrupled in the last three years.
Anderson has cut his Google ad spending to roughly half its earlier level and keeps pulling back as costs rise. He wants a way to buy guaranteed placement inside AI Overviews, but Google offers no such option, and he has found no reliable way to be mentioned there.
Our Read
This is the clearest evidence yet that AI search is biting Google’s core business. Its own AI answers now push its ads out of view, and advertisers are responding by pricing the new reality, not by abandoning Google, after a decade of steady returns.
Google’s answer is that AI is expanding search, with queries growing faster than in five years. That may be true for users, but advertisers measure something else: the cost of a click and the chance it is seen. On both measures, the direction of travel is against them.
The tension will not resolve quickly. Google has said it is focused on the search experience first and monetisation second, which means advertisers may wait a long time for the ad formats that would let them buy their way back into the AI answers.
Why It Matters
Search advertising fell below half of Alphabet’s $128 billion quarterly revenue for the first time last month, and search ad revenue grew 12%, short of the 15% Wall Street expected. If advertisers keep shifting budgets, the gap between user growth and ad growth will widen.
The shift also matters for everyone who buys attention online. If Google cannot monetise AI search as well as the old results page, the money will flow to streaming, social and rival search engines, and the economics of the whole web will move with it.
Background
Google has already admitted that ads in AI Mode earn less per query than traditional search ads. The company is testing ways to sell placement inside its AI answers, but advertisers say there is still no guarantee an ad will show, or be seen, in the new formats.
Pichai told investors the company is focused on building the best search experience, followed by monetisation. A Google spokesperson said ad experiments have shown promising results and the company is confident about its trajectory, even as advertisers hedge their budgets.
Source: The New York Times on Google’s AI disruption and Search Engine Land on the spending cuts


0 Comments