More than 500 Google employees have signed a petition asking the company to let schools use Search without its AI features, after Google said schools that switch off AI would lose Search too. The union behind the petition says educators, not Google, should decide how AI enters the classroom.
The Alphabet Workers Union, part of the Communications Workers of America, published its statement on November 19. It argues that cutting off Search punishes schools for a choice Google itself forces on them, and warns the move will push districts away from Google products altogether.
Districts Are Already Looking Elsewhere
The concern is not hypothetical. The New York Times reports that school districts in New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago are all considering a different search engine rather than accept Google’s terms. A New York City Council letter demanded answers from Google by November 19.
Google’s position is that Search and AI are now deeply integrated, so a school that bans AI features cannot keep Search. The union’s reply is blunt: Google ran Search for decades before Gemini existed, and bundling the two now is a business choice, not a technical necessity.
The petition follows Google’s earlier move to give schools separate controls over Gemini in education, which left Search tied to AI in practice. The union says the new petition asks leadership to reconsider and restore a clean split between the two.
Our Read
Google’s argument has a hole the union found quickly. If Search truly could not run without Gemini, the company could never have sold Search to schools before 2023. The bundling looks less like engineering and more like distribution: every school that keeps Search becomes a Gemini user by default.
That is why the district response matters more than the petition itself. A union letter is easy to ignore; three of America’s largest school districts shopping for another search engine is a procurement threat. Google’s education business depends on districts that now have a reason to leave.
Why It Matters
Schools are where search habits form, and Google has owned that ground for a generation. If districts replace Google Search to escape its AI bundle, the company loses not just contracts but the default status its AI products inherit from Search.
The Wider Pattern
The dispute fits a pattern across Google’s products. Its homepage recently became a Gemini chat app, and AI Mode is spreading through Search. Each step makes Gemini harder to avoid, and each step invites the same complaint: users want the old product without the new assistant attached.
Google has not responded publicly to the petition, and the union has not said what it will do if leadership refuses. The districts weighing alternatives give the story its clock: procurement decisions move slowly, but once a district switches search providers, it rarely switches back.
Background
Google’s school policy has seesawed all month. Earlier in November it offered schools separate controls for Gemini, a step the union welcomed in part. The new requirement that some AI stay switched on for Search to work is what turned a partial win into this week’s petition.
Source: Engadget on the schools petition


0 Comments